Monday to Friday, 09:30-13:30 and 16:30-19:30. Santander, Cantabria
Case law commentary

Inheritance 2026: the inheritance tax relief that applies is the one in force on the date of death

Analysis of judgment 37/2026 of 25 May (ECLI:ES:TC:2026:37) on which rules govern Spanish inheritance tax where a person is judicially recognised as a child of the deceased years after the death.

What the court decided

In judgment 37/2026 of 25 May (constitutional appeal 2593-2024, ECLI:ES:TC:2026:37), the Spanish Constitutional Court holds that it does not breach the right to equality and to freedom from discrimination on grounds of birth under article 14 of the Spanish Constitution, read with article 39.2, to refuse a regional inheritance tax relief that was not in force on the date of the deceased's death, even where the appellant's parentage outside marriage was established by a court later and with retroactive effect. The tax fell due on the date of death under article 24.1 of Act 29/1987, and the applicable rules are those of that date.

Background and prior doctrine

Article 24.1 of Act 29/1987 on inheritance and gift tax sets the date on which the tax falls due as the date of the deceased's death, and that date governs which rules apply: the rates, the kinship reductions and the regional reliefs in force on that day. Article 24.3 creates an exception for acquisitions whose effect is suspended by a condition, a time limit, a trust or any other restriction, which are deemed to take place on the day those restrictions disappear. The case turned on whether parentage proceedings fall within that exception. The deceased died in October 2006 leaving the appellant a legacy rather than a forced share; the appellant challenged the parentage recorded in the civil register and obtained a judgment declaring his paternal parentage in April 2008, upheld on appeal in November 2009. In the meantime the region had enacted a relief of 99.9 per cent of the tax due with effect from 1 January 2008. The tax authorities assessed the tax applying the kinship reduction in force in 2006 and refused the relief. The High Court of Justice and then the Supreme Court, on appeal, upheld that approach before the matter reached the Constitutional Court.

Why the court reached that conclusion

The Court restates its case law on article 14 of the Constitution, namely equal treatment for equal situations, differences that are justified and proportionate, and the specific prohibition of discrimination on grounds of birth, together with the duty under article 39.2 to treat parentage within and outside marriage alike. On that basis it reasons that the refusal of the relief is not founded on the origin of the appellant's parentage but on the date the tax fell due: the tax fell due when the deceased died, and at that time the relief did not exist. It frames the equality test on a precise comparator: a child born within marriage, or a child born outside marriage already acknowledged by the deceased, who had taken part in that same estate would not have been able to apply the relief either. It concludes that the appellant is not asking to be treated like them but better, and that article 14 does not support that claim. The Court also rejects the argument that article 24.3 of the Act allows the chargeable date to be moved to the date the parentage judgment became final: that provision concerns restrictions that suspend the effect of an acquisition, and parentage declared with retroactive effect is not one of them. The dissenting opinion by the reporting judge takes issue precisely with that comparator and argues that there was indirect discrimination on grounds of birth, given that the appellant was not a forced heir when the succession opened and was in no position to pay the tax at the time.

Practical points

  • The date that determines which law governs an estate is the date of death, not the date of the paperwork, the acceptance of the inheritance or the judgment deciding who the heirs are. It is worth establishing that date on the documents before calculating anything.
  • Where the regional inheritance tax rules have changed between the death and the assessment, the calculation must use the rules in force on the date of death, even if the later ones are more favourable. This bears directly on old estates settled years late.
  • Proceedings about parentage, about challenging paternity or about establishing heirship do not move the date on which the tax falls due. Assuming otherwise can turn a justified delay into a surcharge.
  • Where court proceedings affecting who inherits are under way, it is worth considering suspension of the filing deadlines under the regulations implementing the tax, which is a different question from the chargeable date, and recording the exact date on which the matter became contested.
  • Where tax was paid without applying a relief that was in force on the date of death, a request to correct the self-assessment may be available while the year is not time-barred. The rule in this judgment works both ways.
  • In an estate with possible unacknowledged children, the risk is not only a civil one: an assessment already made may have to be redone years later under the old rules. Anticipating this in the will and in the division of the estate avoids the problem.

When this may be relevant to your matter

Estates that are settled years late are more common than people think: parentage proceedings, a complicated declaration of heirship, a disagreement between siblings that stalls the division. When the estate is finally settled, the temptation is to apply the tax rules in force on that day, and this judgment says otherwise: the rules are those of the date of death, with the reductions and reliefs of that time, even if they have changed several times since. In Cantabria, where the regional inheritance tax reliefs have been amended at various points, that means looking at the date of death before looking at the current calendar. If you have an estate that has been waiting to be settled for some time, if court proceedings affect who the heirs are, or if the tax authorities are claiming against you over an old succession, the applicable rules are not necessarily the ones in force today. At Lastra y Herrero Abogados we handle inheritance and succession matters in Santander and throughout Cantabria, including inheritance tax filings, applications to correct self-assessments and defence against tax authority reviews, in Spanish and in English.

If you need advice on a matter of this kind, you can see how the firm works on our page for Inheritance lawyers in Santander.