Monday to Friday, 09:30-13:30 and 16:30-19:30. Santander, Cantabria
Case law commentary

Family law 2026: school books and uniforms are ordinary expenses and are already covered by child maintenance

Commentary on Supreme Court judgment 500/2017 of 13 September, which reiterates the doctrine established in judgment 579/2014: back-to-school costs are ordinary expenses, fall within the legal concept of maintenance and must be spread across the monthly payments.

What the court decided

In judgment 500/2017 of 13 September (appeal 2950/2016), reiterating the doctrine established in judgment 579/2014 of 15 October and applied again in judgment 557/2016 of 21 September, the Spanish Supreme Court holds that the costs arising at the beginning of each school year are ordinary expenses, fall within the legal concept of maintenance under article 142 of the Civil Code, and must be taken into account when setting maintenance by spreading them across the twelve monthly payments.

Background and prior doctrine

For years, first-instance family courts and Courts of Appeal took inconsistent approaches: some treated September costs as extraordinary — and therefore separately claimable and shared in halves — while others regarded them as covered by the maintenance payment. The inconsistency generated a recurring dispute between parents at the start of every school year, with claims for book, uniform and materials invoices ending up in enforcement proceedings. The First Chamber settled the question in judgment 579/2014 and has reiterated it since.

Why the court reached that conclusion

The Chamber's reasoning is conceptual. These costs are necessary for the children's education and therefore fall within the legal concept of maintenance; and they arise every year, which makes them recurring and foreseeable. The boundary between ordinary and extraordinary expenses does not lie in the outlay being concentrated on a particular date, but in foreseeability: an extraordinary expense is one where it is not known whether or when it will occur — medical or dental treatment not covered by the public health system, remedial tuition arising from an unforeseen difficulty, urgent healthcare costs. Being foreseeable and annual, school costs must be factored into the monthly maintenance figure rather than claimed separately.

Practical points

  • Before claiming — or refusing to pay — read the settlement agreement: if it expressly regulates school costs, it prevails over the general doctrine.
  • If the agreement is silent, books, materials, uniform, enrolment at a school the child already attended, school meals and transport are covered by the maintenance payment.
  • If maintenance was set without factoring in the real cost of schooling, or financial circumstances have changed, the correct route is an application to vary the measures.
  • Extracurricular activities and school trips are the grey area: it matters whether they were established before the separation and whether the other parent consented. It is advisable to agree in writing which activities are shared and up to what amount.
  • Keeping receipts and written exchanges about each expense makes it easier to establish the other parent's consent if a dispute arises later.

When this may be relevant to your matter

This is one of the most frequent disputes in Santander and across Cantabria every September: one parent claims half the cost of books and uniforms, the other considers it already covered by the monthly payment. This doctrine makes it possible to know in advance who is right, which almost always depends on what the settlement agreement says. If the maintenance figure set at the time does not reflect the real cost of schooling, the answer is not to fight invoice by invoice but to have the measures reviewed. We advise international and English-speaking parents on these matters.

If you need advice on a matter of this kind, you can see how the firm works on our page for Family lawyers in Santander.