What the court decided
The Spanish Supreme Court examines in STS 5638/2025 the requirements for a successful state liability claim against the legislature in connection with the local capital gains tax (IIVTNU) where the taxpayer proves there was no actual increase in value on the transfer and the assessment had become final by the time the unconstitutionality of the calculation system was declared.
Background and prior doctrine
Constitutional Court judgment STC 182/2021 declared Articles 107(1), 107(2)(a) and 110(4) of the Local Finance Act void in so far as they subject to taxation situations where no increase in value occurred. However, the Constitutional Court limited the effects of its ruling: it does not allow review of final assessments, meaning that state legislative liability is the only available route for those cases.
Why the court reached that conclusion
The Chamber requires that the general conditions for state liability be met: effective harm, economically quantifiable and specific to the claimant; a causal link to the unconstitutional provision; and proof that the harm is not the consequence of a situation the taxpayer could have challenged within the ordinary time limits. Evidence of the absence of any increase in value is central to establishing the unlawful harm.
Practical points
- A state liability claim for local capital gains tax requires: a final assessment, proof of the absence of any real increase in value, and an effective and quantifiable loss.
- State legislative liability is the only available route for assessments that became final before the publication of STC 182/2021 (published in the Official Gazette on 26 October 2021).
- Evidence of the acquisition and transfer at comparable or lower prices — title deeds, valuations — is essential to establish the absence of a taxable gain.
- The one-year limitation period running from the publication of STC 182/2021 has already expired for most cases; any remaining situations should be checked for specific circumstances.
When this may be relevant to your matter
If you paid local capital gains tax on a transfer where the property sold for the same price or less than you paid for it, and that assessment was final in October 2021, state legislative liability was the only available route. The ordinary deadline expired in October 2022, though specific circumstances may still make it worth examining your case.
If you need advice on a matter of this kind, you can see how the firm works on our page for Administrative lawyers in Santander.