Monday to Friday, 09:30-13:30 and 16:30-19:30. Santander, Cantabria
Case law commentary

Inheritance 2026: a will can limit the usufruct of family business shares to dividends actually distributed

Commentary on STS 749/2026 of 13 May on the usufruct of shares: the liquidation rule of Article 128 of the Companies Act is non-mandatory and the testator's wishes prevail.

What the court decided

In STS 749/2026 of 13 May, the First Chamber dismisses the claim brought by the heirs of a usufructuary of shares who demanded from the bare owner the increase in value corresponding to profits carried to reserves during the usufruct — more than €15 million — under Article 128 of the Spanish Companies Act. The testator had provided that the usufruct 'shall be confined only to the dividends actually distributed by the companies', and the Supreme Court holds that the statutory liquidation rule is non-mandatory, so the testator's wishes prevail.

Background and prior doctrine

Granting the surviving spouse a usufruct over shares is a common device in family business succession: it guarantees the spouse an income without fragmenting control of the company. Article 128 of the Companies Act entitles the usufructuary, on termination of the usufruct, to claim from the bare owner the increase in the value of the shares attributable to operating profits carried to reserves during its term. In this case the company distributed hardly any dividends during the nine years of the usufruct and the profits remained in reserves, prompting the claim by the usufructuary's heirs on her death. The Court of First Instance and the Barcelona Court of Appeal had already dismissed the claim.

Why the court reached that conclusion

The Chamber relies on the hierarchy of sources in Articles 67.2 of the former Public Companies Act and 127.2 of the Companies Act: the internal relationship between usufructuary and bare owner is governed first by the title creating the usufruct — here, the will — then by company law and, in the alternative, by the applicable civil law. For reasons of valuative coherence, that non-mandatory nature applies to shares and to company quotas alike. And the word 'only' in the will was no oversight: the testator intended his wife to receive exclusively the dividends resolved and distributed, precisely so that retained profits would not leave the company and it would remain stable under the son designated to run it.

Practical points

  • Anyone planning their succession with company shares may expressly limit the usufruct to dividends actually distributed, excluding any later claim over reserves.
  • Anyone receiving a usufruct of shares limited to dividends should be aware that the general meeting effectively controls how much they will receive; counterweights such as minimum dividends agreed in a family protocol or alternative income are worth considering.
  • The criterion applies equally to public and private limited companies.
  • If an existing will contains a usufruct over shares or quotas, its exact wording should be reviewed before a dispute arises: adverbs matter.

When this may be relevant to your matter

If you are planning the handover of a family business through a will granting your spouse a usufruct of shares, or if you are a usufructuary or bare owner anticipating a dispute over undistributed profits, this doctrine determines who is entitled to what. The precise drafting of the clause can make a very significant economic difference.

If you need advice on a matter of this kind, you can see how the firm works on our page for Inheritance lawyers in Santander.